Dominar vs. Benelli: Drag Race and Comprehensive Motorcycle Comparison

This episode features a drag race between the Dominar and Benelli, detailing their specifications and performance across various launch types. A comprehensive review categorizes each motorcycle's ideal use for city or highway riding, evaluating serviceability, traffic handling, and overall quality.

image

Key Points Summary

  • Dominar Specifications

    The Dominar produces 26 horsepower at 8500 rpm and 23.5 Newton meters of torque at 6500 rpm, with its lower-speed torque contributing to faster acceleration.

  • Benelli Specifications

    The Benelli offers 31.5 horsepower from its two cylinders, but its torque is lower at 21 Newton meters at 900 rpm.

  • Drag Race Observations

    Initial zero-to-launch tests showed minimal performance difference, whereas rolling launches revealed a clearer distinction between the two motorcycles.

  • Weight Discrepancy

    The Benelli is significantly heavier, weighing 196-200 kg, compared to the Dominar's 180 kg.

  • Launch Performance

    The Dominar demonstrates a strong first-gear initial launch, partly due to its high torque, while the Benelli's twin-cylinder engine also provides good initial acceleration despite its weight.

  • Gearbox Characteristics

    Both motorcycles feature long gearboxes, with the first gear being particularly extended.

  • City vs. Highway Suitability

    The Benelli is recommended for highway use and less congested routes, as its powerful nature can become inconvenient for daily city traffic, especially in summer. The Dominar is considered an ideal city bike for daily commuting, despite being relatively heavy for a 250cc single-cylinder motorcycle.

  • Traffic Maneuverability

    Both the Dominar and Benelli are wide and challenging to navigate in heavy city traffic, suggesting scooters might be a more comfortable alternative for extremely congested urban environments.

  • Service and Parts Availability

    The Dominar offers better conditions regarding service and the availability of parts compared to the Benelli.

  • Dominar Tire Concerns

    The Dominar's 130 tires are considered relatively thin for turning, potentially causing insecurity on certain road surfaces, particularly with popular local tire brands.

  • Durability and Quality Comparison

    The Dominar demonstrates high durability, with models reportedly performing well over 70,000-80,000 kilometers, akin to reliable older Indian motorcycles. Conversely, some newer Chinese models, like certain Zontes, have exhibited quality issues such as faulty speed limits or unexpected engine shutdowns on highways.

  • Buyer's Guidance

    The choice between motorcycles depends on primary use: the Benelli appeals to those prioritizing appearance, sound, and raw power, while the Dominar is favored by riders valuing speed, high quality, and long-term durability with less frequent maintenance.

  • Riding Safety Philosophy

    Prioritizing safe riding and enjoying the experience is emphasized over pursuing extreme speeds or engaging in drag races on public roads. High speeds (above 130 km/h) are deemed dangerous given prevailing driving culture and infrastructure, with dedicated tracks being the appropriate venue for performance riding.

Riding a motorcycle safely and enjoying the experience remains paramount, with high speeds and drag racing ideally reserved for dedicated tracks where proper equipment and safety measures are in place.

Under Details

FeatureDominarBenelliInsight
Max Horsepower26 HP @ 8500 rpm31.5 HPBenelli offers higher horsepower, indicative of more top-end power.
Max Torque23.5 Nm @ 6500 rpm21 Nm @ 900 rpmDominar provides higher torque at lower RPM, which aids initial acceleration and city riding.
Weight180 kg196-200 kgBenelli is significantly heavier, potentially impacting agility and fuel efficiency.
City Use SuitabilityIdeal, compact for daily commutingCan be annoying, not ideal for daily city trafficDominar is better suited for urban environments due to its handling characteristics.
Highway Use SuitabilityLess suitable than Benelli for aggressive highway ridingRecommended, considered a 'beast' for highwaysBenelli excels in highway cruising where its power can be utilized effectively.
Service & PartsBetter conditions for service and parts availability/qualityVariable, some quality concerns for newer modelsDominar generally offers a more reliable ownership experience regarding maintenance and parts.
Traffic HandlingWide, challenging to maneuver in heavy trafficWide, challenging to maneuver in heavy trafficBoth motorcycles are less ideal for navigating extremely congested urban areas.
Tires130 tires, relatively thin for turning, potential insecurityNot specifically mentioned as an issueDominar's tire specifications may lead to reduced stability on certain road surfaces.
DurabilityHigh, seen working 70,000-80,000 kmSome newer Chinese models show quality issuesDominar demonstrates superior long-term reliability and build quality.

Tags

Automotive
Motorcycle
Informative
Bikes
Comparison
Share this post