The Epic Research Riddle of Blood Vessel Length: Tracing a Persistent Misinformation

The widely cited fun fact that human blood vessels collectively span 100,000 kilometers sparked an extensive research quest to uncover its original source. This perplexing journey revealed how an early estimate became a persistent truism, despite being based on flawed assumptions and eventually superseded by more accurate scientific calculations.

image

Key Points Summary

  • Prevalence of the 100,000 km Blood Vessel Fact

    The fun fact that all human blood vessels combined measure 100,000 kilometers, enough to wrap around the Earth twice, is widely cited across books, blogs, educational institutions, and scientific papers.

  • Initiation of the Research Riddle

    A crucial problem arose when no original source for the 100,000 km figure could be found, and the number was inconsistently applied—some attributing it to capillaries, others to arteries and veins, or all vessels combined.

  • Initial Difficulties in Tracing the Source

    Initial attempts using general Google searches and biomedical search engines like PubMed yielded no original source. Contacting authors of biology textbooks revealed they also did not know the origin of the long-circulating figure.

  • Tracing Back Through Popular Science Books

    The search narrowed down to the 1990s, identifying 'Vital Circuits' by Steven Vogel and 'Looking at the Body' by David Suzuki as sources. Dr. Suzuki, a prominent science communicator, cited the figure but could not recall its source when contacted personally due to the book being over 30 years old.

  • Breakthrough: Discovering the Scientific American Article

    Steven Vogel's book had a list of 93 references without specific pointers. Fortuitously, checking the sources from last to first led to a 1959 Scientific American article, 'The Microcirculation of the Blood,' which referenced the number.

  • Identification of the Original Source: August Krogh

    The Scientific American article pointed to 'The Anatomy and Physiology of Capillaries,' a 1922 book by Nobel Prize winner August Krogh, confirming it as the original source of the 100,000 km estimate.

  • Krogh's Methodology and Flawed Estimate

    Krogh's estimate was based on cutting muscle samples, counting capillaries, and making assumptions about human capillary density. His calculation used an idealized 143 kg human with 50 kg of pure muscle mass, leading to the 100,000 km figure.

  • Inaccuracy of Krogh's Data

    Later analysis revealed that Krogh's assumptions about human capillary density were quite inaccurate, contributing to the overestimation of the total length.

  • Persistence and Dogmatization of the Flawed Fact

    Despite its inaccuracies, Krogh's estimate, coming from a world expert, was adopted in scientific papers, spread, and became dogma, eventually becoming entirely detached from its original source.

  • Newer Scientific Estimates of Capillary Length

    Recent scientific research, published concurrently with the research riddle, provides a more accurate estimate for the total length of human capillaries, ranging between 9,000 and 19,000 kilometers, a significantly lower figure than the long-held 100,000 km.

  • Challenges in Fact-Checking and Misinformation Persistence

    Thorough fact-checking is extremely time-consuming and difficult, making it unfeasible for most scientists or communicators, who often rely on seemingly credible secondary sources. The memorable and 'beautiful' nature of certain facts contributes to their longevity, even if inaccurate.

  • Commitment to Factual Accuracy

    The organization commits to rigorous research, avoiding mere repetition, questioning initial answers, and persistently verifying information to provide factful, reliable, and up-to-date scientific content.

  • Sponsor: 80,000 Hours

    80,000 Hours is a nonprofit career advice organization offering free, evidence-based guidance to help individuals find fulfilling careers that maximize their positive impact on global issues, often through unconventional paths.

  • Importance of Patron Support

    The extensive time and effort required for such in-depth research and fact-checking are made possible by the continuous support of patrons, enabling the creation of high-quality, trustworthy scientific content.

Facts that seem beautiful tend to survive much longer, leading to the persistence of misinformation.

Under Details

AspectDescriptionImpact
Initial Fact & ProblemThe widely cited claim that human blood vessels total 100,000 km lacked a verifiable original source and showed inconsistent application.Sparked an extensive, year-long research investigation due to its pervasive nature without proper attribution.
Original Source & AuthorThe 100,000 km estimate originated from Nobel laureate August Krogh's 1922 book, 'The Anatomy and Physiology of Capillaries'.Krogh was the first to make an estimate based on real experiments, lending immediate credibility to the figure.
Methodology & FlawsKrogh's calculation involved muscle samples, capillary counts, and assumptions, using an idealized 143 kg 'bodybuilder' human.His assumptions about human capillary density were later found to be significantly off, leading to an overestimation.
Propagation of MisinformationDespite its inaccuracies, Krogh's estimate from a world expert became dogma, spreading through scientific papers and popular media.The number persisted for over a century, often detached from its source, due to its memorable and 'beautiful' simplicity.
Current Scientific EstimateNewer research estimates the total length of human capillaries to be between 9,000 and 19,000 km.This significantly lower figure provides a more accurate understanding, debunking the long-held 100,000 km claim.
Challenges of VerificationFact-checking requires immense time and effort, making it impractical for many scientists and communicators, who often rely on secondary sources.Contributes to the perpetuation of widely accepted but unverified facts, highlighting the difficulty in correcting misinformation.

Tags

Biology
Fact-checking
Critical
Krogh
Research
Share this post